Cars, funerals and home improvements: EU to crack down on large cash payments

Cash payments over €10,000 for transactions such as car purchases, home improvements or funeral bills will be banned under EU rules expected to come into force within three years.

The EU legislation is being considered in an attempt to clamp down on cross-border money laundering on a wider European basis.

The move could affect a large section of society who choose to operate solely on a cash basis.

Irish EU Commissioner Mairead McGuinness, who is responsible for toughening anti-money laundering laws, says a much broader view of the problem must be taken, moving beyond large-scale businesses, banks and financial institutions.

Ms McGuinness said the focus must now go on things like car purchases, jewellery, antiques and even more unusual items like funeral charges.

“The proposed measures extend the capping for large cash payments to services too, so that for example funeral services above €10,000 would have to be paid through card or via a bank,” Ms McGuinness told the Irish Independent.

“It is a high threshold, as on average funerals in Ireland cost between €3,000 and €7,500,” she said.

The ban is aimed at tackling money laundering but also comes as European authorities are looking towards an increasingly digital society, including plans for a purely digital version of the euro being examined by the European Central Bank.

The European Union’s heaviest cash users are in Germany and Austria where cash remains king for most consumers.

In Sweden, in contrast, digital payments predominate.

Ireland lies between the two extremes.

Cash use here had been declining in recent years and that accelerated during the Covid pandemic.

Some businesses prefer to deal in cash in order to avoid paying tax on income, however rules that dictate how people can spend money are likely to raise privacy and civil liberties concerns.

Even though cash use is down, Irish consumers withdrew €21.44bn from ATMs last year and it remains particularly popular among older people and people in rural areas, according to the Central Bank.

Earlier this year, the Central Bank warned that stigmatising cash shoppers by only accepting card or digital payments risks increasing social isolation and reduces consumer choice.

Ireland is one of eight out of the 27 EU member states which does not have a limit on large cash payments, although existing anti-money laundering rules here already put a cap on carrying large sums in and out of the country and impose reporting obligations on financial institutions and professionals.

Ms McGuinness last month unveiled a scheme of tougher cross-border Brussels laws, including the establishment of a new EU Anti-Money Laundering Agency.

It was a recognition that the EU’s free movement of capital brings great opportunities for big-time criminals to rehabilitate their money back into the legitimate money system and also that cross-border co-operation needs hardening up.

The Commissioner says current EU anti-money laundering rules place obligations on a large share of businesses, not financial institutions.

The list includes accountants, lawyers, trust and company service providers, but also real estate agents, gambling service providers and dealers in works of art.

“As things stand all these businesses are subject to supervision at national level to ensure that they apply anti-money laundering requirements. 

“Our plan is to extend the scope of EU rules to traders in precious metals and stones, professionals assisting third country nationals in obtaining golden visas, and mortgage and consumer credit providers or intermediaries that are not licensed as financial institutions,” she said.

Already there are 19 member states with cash limits in place, and 18 of these have limits at €10,000 or less – and in Greece the limit is fixed in theory at €500.

But this cash limit will be a focus in EU lawmakers’ discussions on Commissioner McGuinness’s proposals.

People in countries like Germany and Austria, which are currently without any limit, regularly make large purchases paying cash.


By John Downing, August 3, 2021, Published on The Irish Independent

Recent Posts